Home/Where to stay/Saint Augustine/Top-rated hotels
Top-rated hotels in Saint Augustine
A shortlist of the top-rated hotels in Saint Augustine, ordered by guest score weighted by the number of stays behind it. Eleven of the 46 stays listed carry a score from verified stays, and these are the best supported of them.
Staying in Saint Augustine
Saint Augustine is a Florida city where visitors come for the historic streets, the waterfront and the beaches along the coast. The hotels on this shortlist sit in three different parts of it: downtown addresses on Valencia St, Cordova Street, W Castillo Dr and San Marco Ave, the coast at 8Th St, A1a Beach Blvd, Ocean Hibiscus Drive and A1a S, and one inland at S Legacy Trail.
The downtown group suits couples and short breaks, with Cordova Street carrying both The Collector Luxury Inn and Gardens and Casa Monica Resort & Spa Autograph Collection. Traders and families who want to be near the historic district have the Renaissance St. Augustine Historic Downtown Hotel and the DoubleTree by Hilton St. Augustine Historic District. The beach addresses, The View, Ocean & Racquet 3 4, Ocean Gate at Hibiscus Resort and Ocean Pearl, suit longer, quieter stays, while the World Golf Village Renaissance St. Augustine Resort stands apart for a resort-style break.
The shortlist
Ranked by guest rating, then number of reviews.
La Valencia
56 Valencia St
Why stay hereLa Valencia earns the highest guest rating on this shortlist, 4.9 out of 5 across 1341 reviews, a record that speaks for itself among 4-star stays in Saint Augustine. Its address on Valencia Street places it away from the busiest blocks while keeping the city within reach. Couples and travellers who weigh guest satisfaction above all else will find the strength of that feedback hard to ignore. With no facility details to draw on, the draw here is the consistency of the experience guests report.
See La ValenciaThe Collector Luxury Inn and Gardens
149 Cordova Street
Why stay hereA 4-star address on Cordova Street, The Collector Luxury Inn and Gardens sits in the historic heart of Saint Augustine, close to the sights that bring most visitors here. Guests rate it 4.7 out of 5 across 521 reviews, a strong score from a substantial body of stays. Its name points to gardens and a collector's spirit, and the Cordova Street setting suits travellers who want to step out into the old city rather than drive to it.
See The Collector Luxury Inn and GardensRenaissance St. Augustine Historic Downtown Hotel
6 W Castillo Dr
Why stay herePositioned on West Castillo Drive, the Renaissance St. Augustine Historic Downtown Hotel is a 4-star property in the historic downtown district, which makes it a practical base for exploring the old city on foot. A guest rating of 4.5 out of 5 comes from 512 reviews, suggesting steady rather than exceptional satisfaction. It suits visitors who want a recognised hotel brand in a central location and prefer a straightforward, well-reviewed stay over a boutique or resort setting.
See Renaissance St. Augustine Historic Downtown HotelWorld Golf Village Renaissance St. Augustine Resort
500 S Legacy Trail
Why stay hereWith 3215 reviews and a 4.4 out of 5 guest rating, the World Golf Village Renaissance St. Augustine Resort is the most reviewed property on this list, evidence of a busy, established operation. It stands at 500 South Legacy Trail, well away from the historic downtown streets, which suits golfers and travellers who want a resort setting outside the city centre. Those who value volume of feedback as a guide will find plenty to read here.
See World Golf Village Renaissance St. Augustine ResortCasa Monica Resort & Spa Autograph Collection
95 Cordova St
Why stay hereCasa Monica Resort & Spa Autograph Collection occupies 95 Cordova Street, placing it squarely among the historic downtown blocks, and the name promises both spa facilities and resort comforts for guests who want them on site. Travellers drawn to a landmark-style address in the old city, and to a spa within the building, are the natural audience.
See Casa Monica Resort & Spa Autograph CollectionThe View by Distinctive Beach Rentals
4 8Th St
Why stay hereThe View by Distinctive Beach Rentals takes its name from the outlook its guests come for, and the 8th Street address puts it among the beachside properties rather than the downtown historic quarter. A 4.4 out of 5 rating drawn from 2945 reviews makes it one of the most reviewed options here, so the feedback is substantial. It suits visitors who want a rental-style stay near the sand and are happy to be outside the old city.
See The View by Distinctive Beach RentalsDoubleTree by Hilton St. Augustine Historic District
116 San Marco Ave
Why stay hereThe DoubleTree by Hilton St. Augustine Historic District offers a 4-star stay on San Marco Avenue, on the approach to the historic district rather than inside it, which many guests find a convenient compromise. Its 4.3 out of 5 rating rests on 1537 reviews, a solid record. Travellers who prefer a familiar international brand and a location within reach of the old city will find this a sensible choice for a Saint Augustine visit.
See DoubleTree by Hilton St. Augustine Historic DistrictOcean & Racquet 3 4 by VTrips
880 A1a Beach Blvd St. Augustine
Why stay hereOcean & Racquet 3 4 by VTrips sits at 880 A1a Beach Boulevard, an address that places it in the beachside stretch of Saint Augustine rather than the colonial centre. Its 4.3 out of 5 rating comes from 840 reviews, enough to give a fair picture of what to expect. The property suits guests planning a coastal stay built around the beach and the A1A, with the historic sights a separate outing rather than a walk away.
See Ocean & Racquet 3 4 by VTripsOcean Gate at Hibiscus Resort
125 Ocean Hibiscus Drive
Why stay hereOcean Gate at Hibiscus Resort is a 4-star property on Ocean Hibiscus Drive, and its name signals a resort-style setting on the island side of Saint Augustine. A 4.3 out of 5 guest rating is based on 254 reviews, a smaller but consistent sample. It fits travellers who want a quieter, resort-oriented base near the ocean and are content to leave the historic downtown for day trips rather than stay in the middle of it.
See Ocean Gate at Hibiscus ResortOcean Pearl by Distinctive Beach Rentals
7090 A1a S
Why stay hereThe highest rating on this list after La Valencia belongs to Ocean Pearl by Distinctive Beach Rentals, 4.8 out of 5, though it rests on just 23 reviews, so treat it as an early signal rather than a settled verdict. Its address on A1A South places it along the beach corridor south of the city. It suits visitors who want a beach rental and are willing to weigh a small but very positive body of guest feedback.
See Ocean Pearl by Distinctive Beach Rentals
How to choose
Downtown and historic
These five sit on Valencia St, Cordova Street, W Castillo Dr and San Marco Ave, the addresses closest to the historic heart of Saint Augustine. Casa Monica Resort & Spa Autograph Collection and The Collector Luxury Inn and Gardens share Cordova Street, and both hold a 4.4 and 4.7 guest rating, so the choice between them comes down to which side of the street you prefer.
La Valencia · The Collector Luxury Inn and Gardens · Renaissance St. Augustine Historic Downtown Hotel · Casa Monica Resort & Spa Autograph Collection · DoubleTree by Hilton St. Augustine Historic District
Coastal stays
Four of the shortlist face the coast, at 8Th St, A1a Beach Blvd, Ocean Hibiscus Drive and A1a S. Ocean Pearl by Distinctive Beach Rentals holds the highest guest score on this shortlist at 4.8, from 23 reviews, while The View by Distinctive Beach Rentals has 2945 reviews behind its 4.4.
The View by Distinctive Beach Rentals · Ocean & Racquet 3 4 by VTrips · Ocean Gate at Hibiscus Resort · Ocean Pearl by Distinctive Beach Rentals
Well reviewed
Ranked by guest score, La Valencia leads at 4.9 from 1341 reviews, Ocean Pearl follows at 4.8 from 23, and The Collector Luxury Inn and Gardens at 4.7 from 521. Renaissance St. Augustine Historic Downtown Hotel at 4.5 from 512 completes the group with the strongest review base among the downtown addresses.
La Valencia · Ocean Pearl by Distinctive Beach Rentals · The Collector Luxury Inn and Gardens · Renaissance St. Augustine Historic Downtown Hotel
Resort and golf
World Golf Village Renaissance St. Augustine Resort is the only shortlisted hotel at S Legacy Trail. It is a 4-star with a 4.4 guest rating from 3215 reviews, the largest review count on this shortlist, and its inland address sets it apart from the downtown and coastal stays.
Where to stay in Saint Augustine
Cordova Street
Staying here puts you in the downtown group of the shortlist, within reach of the other historic-district addresses on Valencia St, W Castillo Dr and San Marco Ave.
Our picks here: The Collector Luxury Inn and Gardens
A1a
Ocean & Racquet 3 4 by VTrips at 880 A1a Beach Blvd and Ocean Pearl by Distinctive Beach Rentals at 7090 A1a S both sit on A1a. These are the coastal addresses of the shortlist, alongside 4 8Th St and 125 Ocean Hibiscus Drive, and they suit guests who want the beach rather than the historic streets.
Our picks here: Ocean & Racquet 3 4 by VTrips · Ocean Pearl by Distinctive Beach Rentals
Questions, answered
Which hotel on this shortlist has the highest guest rating?
La Valencia has the highest guest score at 4.9, from 1341 reviews, and it is the first entry on the shortlist. Ocean Pearl by Distinctive Beach Rentals is next at 4.8, but from 23 reviews, and The Collector Luxury Inn and Gardens follows at 4.7 from 521.
Which hotel is closest to the centre?
The addresses nearest the centre are those on Cordova Street and W Castillo Dr: Casa Monica Resort & Spa Autograph Collection and The Collector Luxury Inn and Gardens on Cordova Street, and Renaissance St. Augustine Historic Downtown Hotel on W Castillo Dr.
Are there hotels on this shortlist near the beach?
Yes. The View by Distinctive Beach Rentals at 4 8Th St, Ocean & Racquet 3 4 by VTrips at 880 A1a Beach Blvd, Ocean Gate at Hibiscus Resort at 125 Ocean Hibiscus Drive and Ocean Pearl by Distinctive Beach Rentals at 7090 A1a S all have coastal addresses.
Which hotel has the most reviews?
World Golf Village Renaissance St. Augustine Resort has 3215 reviews, the largest count on the shortlist, behind its 4.4 guest rating. Casa Monica Resort & Spa Autograph Collection has 2946 and The View by Distinctive Beach Rentals 2945.
Which is the best pick for families?
World Golf Village Renaissance St. Augustine Resort, with 3215 reviews and a 4.4 rating, is the resort-style option inland at S Legacy Trail. Downtown, the Renaissance St. Augustine Historic Downtown Hotel and the DoubleTree by Hilton St. Augustine Historic District on San Marco Ave keep families in the historic district.
Are all the hotels on this shortlist four-star?
Yes. Every hotel here is classed 4-star by the booking supplier. Casa Monica Resort & Spa Autograph Collection, La Valencia, The Collector Luxury Inn and Gardens, Renaissance St. Augustine Historic Downtown Hotel, World Golf Village Renaissance St. Augustine Resort and the coastal properties all sit in the same class.
Where exactly are these hotels in Saint Augustine?
They fall into three groups: downtown, on Valencia St, Cordova Street, W Castillo Dr and San Marco Ave; the coast, at 4 8Th St, 880 A1a Beach Blvd, 125 Ocean Hibiscus Drive and 7090 A1a S; and inland at 500 S Legacy Trail.